Masthead banner of Park Science: Integrating Research and Resource Management in the National Parks; ISSN 1090-9966; link to current issue
Volume 28
Number 3
Winter 2011-2012
Arrowhead symbol of the National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior
Home + About + Author Guidelines + Archive + Subscribe +  
Map showing difference in fire return interval departure index between actual and modeled landscapes for South Fork of the Merced watershed, Yosemite National Park, California. Science Feature
The hidden consequences of fire suppression

By Carol Miller
Published: 4 Sep 2015 (online)  •  14 Sep 2015 (in print)
Models used
Consequences of fire suppression
About the author
+ PDF +

Excluding fire can have dramatic effects on ecosystems. Decades of fire suppression in national parks and other protected areas have altered natural fire regimes, vegetation, and wildlife habitat (Chang 1996; Keane et al. 2002). Suppressing lightning-ignited wildfires removes one of the most important natural processes from fire-dependent ecosystems, and runs counter to the untrammeled characteristics for which wilderness is to be managed. Many, if not most, lightning-ignited fires are suppressed in wilderness for myriad reasons and yet resource specialists have not had a good way to measure or monitor the effects of these management actions. What if we did not suppress these fires? Where would these fires have spread, and what would the effects have been? Can we quantify the impacts of suppressing these fires?

Recently, we asked these questions for two case study areas in the Sierra Nevada of California, both of which are almost entirely designated wilderness: the 74,057-acre (29,970 ha) South Fork of the Merced River watershed in Yosemite National Park and the 223,573-acre (90,480 ha) Upper Kaweah watershed in Sequoia–Kings Canyon National Parks. Yosemite and Sequoia–Kings Canyon National Parks have been leaders in the restoration of fire as a natural process. By 1970, both parks had instituted a policy whereby lightning-caused fires could be allowed to burn in certain areas. Despite these efforts, the parks continue to struggle with restoring natural fire regimes, and the majority of lightning-caused ignitions are suppressed for myriad biophysical and social reasons. For example, most of the South Fork of the Merced watershed has not burned since before the 1930s. This watershed contains the townsite of Wawona and the Mariposa grove of giant sequoia trees (Sequoiadendron giganteum), and fires are typically suppressed, which has led to unnaturally high fuel accumulations. In the Upper Kaweah watershed in Sequoia–Kings Canyon, about half of the lightning-caused ignitions are suppressed. The Upper Kaweah watershed contains most of the park’s infrastructure and giant sequoia groves, and has a diversity of boundary interface issues. Because of the watershed’s proximity to developed areas and topography that drains into the San Joaquin Valley, smoke and its impacts on air quality are a primary concern.

Return to top

This page updated:  6 February 2012

Page 1 of 6 • Next +
From the Guest Editor(s)
A Wilderness Celebration
At Your Service
Masthead Information
Special Issue: Wilderness Stewardship and Science
A conversation with NPS Director Jonathan B. Jarvis
Using wilderness character to improve wilderness stewardship
Using the “Keeping It Wild” framework to develop a wilderness character monitoring protocol for the Otis Pike Fire Island High Dune Wilderness
Lessons learned: Merging process elements to address wilderness character and user capacity
A database application for wilderness character monitoring
Fires in wilderness in the national parks
Transboundary cooperation to achieve wilderness protection and large landscape conservation
Integrating cultural resources and wilderness character
Climate change: Wilderness’s greatest challenge
Climate change threatens wilderness integrity
The science of trail surveys
Wilderness visitor experiences
Scientific study and enduring wilderness
  The hidden consequences of fire suppression
Using acoustical data to manage for solitude in wilderness areas
Creating exploratory maps for wilderness impact surveys: Applications in campsite searches
Spiritual outcomes of wilderness experience
Remote sensing of heritage resources for research and management
Managing overnight stock use at Yosemite National Park
Economic impacts of search-and-rescue operations on wilderness management in the national parks
Through the looking glass: What value will we see in wilderness in 2064?
Related Publications + Explore Nature + + Privacy + Disclaimer + Contact Editor
Web Site Last Updated: 16 September 2015