Four-wheel drive road passing through Salt Creek at Canyonlands National Park, Utah Category--Long-term Monitoring; Headline--Riparian Monitoring Focused on Stream Recovery in Canyonlands
by Charlie Schelz
After nearly 50 years of use, the road above Peekaboo Camp in Salt Creek of the Needles District of Canyonlands National Park (Utah) was closed to vehicles in 1998. The rough, four-wheel-drive route ran in and across the creek in many places and provided access to Angel Arch, a popular destination 12 miles from the trailhead. The closure is the result of a lawsuit brought by a wilderness advocacy group to reverse a park decision to allow limited vehicular use of the road. In 1992 the park began a backcountry use planning process and examined the long-standing policy of unrestricted use of the Salt Creek road. The issue is a classic example of balancing resource use and preservation. Although the preferred alternative in the environmental assessment for the backcountry management plan was for road closure, the park decided to limit use through a permit system. The court overturned that decision last July.

Salt Creek is the only perennial stream in the park besides the Colorado and Green Rivers. It has been the subject of three studies by various independent researchers who attempted to determine the effects of vehicular traffic on the ecosystem. All of these studies, although neither well funded nor extensive, found deleterious ecological effects of the road and its use. The extensive literature on the effects of such roads on ecosystem processes has also shown many negative consequences, especially in arid environments. These include increased erosion, habitat destruction, soil and water pollution, noise pollution, exotic invasions, and wildlife elimination and dispersion.

With the road now closed and left to the forces of nature, the park Division of Resource Management has initiated a riparian monitoring program to document ecological change and natural recovery in Salt Creek. In 1998, the park established 12 permanent plots in Salt Creek that record biological, hydrologic, erosion, and vegetation features as they appear now. The park plans to measure these same features again in the future, possibly every three to five years. It also plans to establish plots in the section of Salt Creek that is still open to vehicles and in similar adjacent canyons.

The monitoring program has many objectives and methods. First, the park wants to determine any change in vegetation composition, cover, and structure at each plot using a cross-sectional, line-intersect method. The park plans to measure, photograph, and map stream channel characteristics. Permanent panoramic photo-points will be set up above and in the stream channel at each plot. Aquatic macroinvertebrate populations will be monitored along both open and closed sections of the road, and a permanent bird survey transect will be set up in the closed section of Salt Creek. Amphibian and insect surveys may also be added in 1999. Finally, the park plans a Riparian Functioning Condition Analysis, developed by the Bureau of Land Management, at each site to assess the quality of the riparian condition by examining vegetation, hydrology, and erosion.

This study is the first of its kind in the semiarid environment of the Colorado Plateau. Now in its infancy, the monitoring program is envisioned as long-term and will add much to the ecological understanding of riparian recovery and change in an arid environment following disturbance.

Arrow pointing to photo
Located in the Needles District of Canyonlands National Park, the scenic four-wheel-drive road to Angel Arch was closed to vehicles in 1998. The area is now the site of resource monitoring designed to increase ecological understanding of riparian recovery in an arid landscape following disturbance.

Photo Credit: Southeast Utah Group, Charlie Schelz

charlie_schelz@nps.gov
Biologist, Southeast Utah Group; Moab, Utah

Back to Chapter 2: NPS Science

Shoreline studies at Padre Island point to trash sources
by John Miller

White abalone: Going, going, gone?
by Gary E. Davis

Science-based planning at Tallgrass Prairie National Preserve
by John Neal and George Oviatt

Recurrent themes of water resources management plans
by David L. Vana-Miller

Program Center takes on geologic inventories
by Bruce Heise and Joe Gregson

Bats surveyed at Grand Canyon
by Elaine Leslie

Survey research provides management information
by Jean E. McKendry

Home


/YearInReview/yir/yir98/chapter02/chapter02pg3.html
Last Updated: 07/22/99
Direct comments on this website to jeff_selleck@nps.gov
This article is from Natural Resource Year in Review--1998, published by the National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior, in June 1999 (publication D-1346)